Islamorada Fish Company in Islamorada

81532 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036-3701, Islamorada

Overview

Cuisine
  • American
  • Seafood
  • Soups
  • Vegetarian Friendly
  • Vegan Options
  • Gluten Free Options
Features
  • Takeout
  • Outdoor Seating
  • Seating
  • Waitstaff
  • Parking Available
  • Highchairs Available
  • Wheelchair Accessible
  • Serves Alcohol
  • Full Bar
Good for
  • Scenic view
  • Kids
  • Families witd children
  • Large groups
  • Local cuisine
  • Bar scene
  • Special occasions

Restaurant Hours

Monday

11:00 am

Wednesday

11:00 am

Friday

11:00 am

Sunday

11:00 am

What time is the tarpon feeding?

I believe it's all day long. But if you call IslaMorada Fish Company directly you'll get a more accurate answer

How is the weather now?

Google it for accurate information

You guys all cleaned, up from the strom??

They've been cleaned up from the storm months ago

Who is the entertainer who sets on the stool and plays the guitar barefoot?

His name is Dennis Holmes

Does the tiki hut have happy hour?

Yes.

What mile marker?

Part of the Bass Pro Shop

Howfresh is their seafood? Not Sysco freshly frozen then thawed, I hope?

Its fresh-ish but the portions are small.

Do you sell coolers to ship fish back. If so how much for a cooler that holds 50 pounds ?

Islamorada Fish Company is a restaurant. While they will cook your catch, that is a single fish to go with a meal. There is a fish market on site I believe. It was closed for remodelling when I went to go in. As someone else said, probably best to call. Im sure they can point you in right direction. 50 lbs of whole fish will be significantly less once fileted or steaked depending on species. Worldwide Fisherman which is at this location is BPS saltwater and they sell Yeti coolers.

How much is your bring your own fish for seven?

You should call the restaurant directly if you want an accurate answer.

are dogs welcome on patio

If you call the restaurant directly and speak to a manager you'll get accurate information

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Islamorada Fish Company
MM
Michael Miranda
google
11.21.2024
5/5

That mango drink was off the chain!! Great place for the munchies .. 😎

Islamorada Fish Company
rl
renata laboissiere
google
11.22.2018
5/5

Great experience! Food and service excellent!

Islamorada Fish Company
SL
Sofía Lozano Garza
google
10.05.2018
5/5

Best conch fritters in town and the best key lime pie of the keys. Their location is great right by the water and had some pelicans fly by. Good service and food

Islamorada Fish Company
DS
Donald Snowden
google
09.27.2018
1/5

Drove all the way from Boca! Always love the live music here! Was told on the phone, music was there then we get there and no music and they said they don't know when music will be back. Other places have music but we really love the vibe and music there. Wasted a day driving down for nothing.

Islamorada Fish Company
DP
Dylan Perez
google
09.25.2018
5/5

The food is slightly more expensive but the quality is authentic and fantastic; highly recommended if you need to stop at a restaurant in the way down the keys ✨👌

Islamorada Fish Company
KD
Ken D
google
09.06.2018
1/5

Used to be great. Now horrible.Not for locals.Bartenders are rude. Waitress had too many tables. Food was definitely from food distributor (US Foods). Not local not fresh. Couldn’t even finish the peel & eat shrimpGo to Lorelei’s.

Islamorada Fish Company
DM
Donald Mansmann
google
07.26.2018
4/5

Good food. Great drinks. Fantastic service. But the outdoor dining and the views are what distinguishes this place. It is well worth stopping in if you are driving between Key West and Miami. For information, our grouper sandwiches were something like $20 each. It seemed expensive. But, maybe that's the norm for the area.

Islamorada Fish Company
TG
That Guy
google
06.16.2018
1/5

Had blackened scallop and shrimp pasta. 2 scallops, 3 shrimp. Not blackened. Very heavy and greasy pasta. Not happy

Islamorada Fish Company
JD
Jesus Diaz
google
05.25.2018
5/5

Arrived by boat to a very busy marina. Docking was easy and the grounds were nice. Food was delicious and the service was friendly. Definitely a must visit if in the area!

Islamorada Fish Company
VC
Vivían Cueto-Marichal
google
05.21.2018
5/5

Hubbie n I just had tons of oysters there w/beer! Tara was our host at the Bar n she was pleasant n charismatic!!! Will definitely come back! 👍🏼😍👍🏼

Islamorada Fish Company
SG
Sunshine George
google
04.13.2018
5/5

Service was amazing. And the food was delicious. You can also feed huge tarpons they have swimming around. Its cool for the kids.

Islamorada Fish Company
AW
Antoinette Walder
google
04.11.2018
1/5

We showed up an hour and a half before they closed. We had not eaten since 12, we had been stuck in traffic on the highway coming from the keys and we were still an hour and a half away from home. Mentioned this to the hostess, hoping for a compromise (it was only two of us) and she said “you wanna eat here? Right now?!” and then proceeded to tell us we can’t go in. She said the restaurant was closed already for anymore people. Yet I saw tons of tables open. And it wasn’t for coronavirus, because everywhere else, people were jammed in tight. I was really looking forward to eating here. Now, not so much...

Islamorada Fish Company
GB
G B Custom Rods
google
04.09.2018
4/5

Drove a round trip of 140 miles to have lunch there. Figure it out. Fantastic food

Islamorada Fish Company
SS
Steve S
google
04.07.2018
5/5

Outstanding food must try aligator appetizer and huge tarpon frequent the water nearby

Islamorada Fish Company
AC
Angel Cortes
google
03.08.2018
4/5

The view is second to none and the key lime pie is excellent 👌😁 The food overall is fresh and simple. Just a good place to have some appetizers and cocktails while enjoying the ocean view.

Islamorada Fish Company
MV
Misty Van Foeken
google
02.24.2018
2/5

The fish was not fresh, not even close. Very disappointed in the quality of the food. I expected better. Save your money.

Islamorada Fish Company
AC
Angel Chiclana
google
02.18.2018
5/5

This is one of my favorite spots in the US. The food is always good and the location is hard to beat. I've seen sharks, dolphins and turtles right from the peer. We also spotted a water spout once but I digress. The food is always fresh, especially the Fish Dip and catch of the day.

Islamorada Fish Company
AG
Alex Guerra
google
02.02.2018
5/5

Best tasting Fish in the Florida Keys. Had a great yellow tail with shrimp and i could barely make it back to the car. Can't wait to go down again. A must stop in the Keys.

Islamorada Fish Company
RW
Rebecca Wentling
google
11.07.2017
5/5

Excellent fresh cobb salad. Great Rumrunner

Islamorada Fish Company
DM
D. Machelle Anderson
google
10.19.2017
4/5

Come early and walk around and really see this place. Great food and drinks. Live entertainment all the time.

Islamorada Fish Company
RJ
Rebecca Jones
google
10.05.2017
5/5

I have always loved Islamorada Fish Company. So during this times the setting was quite quite different. But as always the service food was wonderful, as is the view

Islamorada Fish Company
FM
Franklin Mathews
google
08.17.2017
2/5

Not sure what happened with our visit today, but cannot give many stars. Location is great and waitress was very friendly. However, waitress came out to apologize after 52 minutes stating our ticket was misplaced and that a rush was placed on our order. Two orders were blacken Hog fish. Never heard of that fish, but was explained to be similar to yellow tail snapper. One order came out grilled blacken, but over cooked. The other plain. My fish and chips were dry. The other order was scallops and that was good. The manager made it right with our bill, but food needs to be worked on.

Islamorada Fish Company
jd
jorge de llano
google
07.25.2017
4/5

Great place awesome atmosphere but long wait over an hour

Islamorada Fish Company
DR
Donna Ridolfino
google
07.24.2017
5/5

Big covered outdoor dining with marina and water view. Large menu, lots of choices no matter your preferences. I had the best ahi tuna salad, loaded with varied ingredients and huge portion of tuna, staff friendly and efficient, good bar drinks, cute little gift shop. Definitely a keeper.

Islamorada Fish Company
MM
Michael Miller
google
07.14.2017
3/5

Disappointed. This was one of my favorite spots years ago, I would love to come for dinner and watch the sun set. Stopped in for lunch on my way to Key West and realized this place has taken a step back. I ordered the Mahi Ruben without cheese. What came was a small piece of fish on bread , for a total cost of $19.95. I ordered the side of greens which came with no dressing or other vegetables. I will certainly give it another go around because of my past experiences but after reading other recent reviews , my expectations will not be high.

Islamorada Fish Company
AA
Art Agramonte
google
06.08.2017
5/5

As always, food is good and the ocean view amazing.

Islamorada Fish Company
AM
Al Martinez
google
06.03.2017
5/5

It was awesome. The fish and chips were great. My waitress was the best. Extremely attentive and friendly. So glad to spend a day down in the Keys.

Islamorada Fish Company
EV
Eduardo Viana
google
05.23.2017
5/5

Loved the fish and fries. The pasta with scallop was also delicious!

Islamorada Fish Company
RE
Robert Edwards
google
04.17.2017
4/5

Beautiful location on the water.

Islamorada Fish Company
AA
Alyona Alyona
google
03.15.2017
5/5

Love the place. It's cozy and beautiful.

Islamorada Fish Company
SF
SHIRAZ FYZOOL
google
02.13.2017
1/5

We headed to restaurant for Sunday brunch and brought along another family of 4 to share our previous experience. Even though the drive down was 1hr extra in traffic, together with a 2hour table wait... we waited to be seated only to be told that 50%+ items on the menu were unavailable, from French fries for the kids to key lime pie dessert. Their appetizers only included 2 items from a menu given to us which didn’t make sense.All in all very disappointed.. they should have told us when we checked in that the menu was limited as wellSorry but now our Sunday brunch will not be here anymore 😾

Islamorada Fish Company
AS
Alan Spies
google
02.11.2017
5/5

Great food. Very good service. Nice atmosphere. Excellent views. Easy parking. Just awesome.

Islamorada Fish Company
LH
Liam H.
google
02.05.2017
5/5

Good food. Great service. Nice view.

Islamorada Fish Company
KN
Kerim Nassar
google
01.23.2017
5/5

Awesome place to go with family and friends or with your loved one and have lunch or dinner or just a couple of drinks and relax enjoy the view and the fresh air. Walk around go to the store its very nice inside well recommended. I had the fish and chips it was excellent the service was amazing my server her name is Jamie she went above and beyond making checking on me if we needed anything at all times and the food was awesome well recommended. Ask for Jamie to be your server she dose a excellent job . I give her an A ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ will be going back again

Islamorada Fish Company
GM
Gabrielle Martonffy
google
10.08.2016
1/5

The worst fish sandwich I have ever had ! The fish was so thin it was not visible , covered by onions and disgusting cheese! Nobody enforced masks, the bar was crowded with young people without masks! I am so disappointed because I was looking forward to a lovely lunch! I have been to this place many times and cannot understand the difference !

Islamorada Fish Company
DH
Dan Hahn
google
08.13.2016
3/5

I'm sorry but this place needs to step it up on their food or drop the prices. You can't have both when it is this bland. Two adults and three kids and it was $145 with tip for sandwiches that weren't very good.☹️

Islamorada Fish Company
bt
be the change
google
07.20.2016
2/5

A server sat a couple he recognized, who arrived after we did. That made the hostess and us very frustrated. Excellent location but we didn't receive cutlery or napkins with our food (so, we ate with our hands). Our server said the key lime pie was freshly baked - it wasn't.

Islamorada Fish Company
DA
Dan Anthony
google
07.13.2016
4/5

Really nice place. Very nice views. Good drinks and good food. Came here recently looking for oysters which we found and were delicious. Stayed for some drinks. The berry mojito was good and refreshing. The mules didn't fizzle so I wouldn't recommend it. Ordered the Island Sampler and everything was good: fish dip, gator bites, conch fritters, coconut shrimps, everything good. Fish dip is the best we have had in the Keys so we bought extra to take home. Staff is Keys level friendly.

Islamorada Fish Company
SB
Sue Bunetta
google
06.21.2016
5/5

Fantastic salad with poppy seed dressing. My peel & eat shrimp were good and my friend said her medium cooked burger was juicy, unusual in that well done. We both enjoyed the sweet potato tots. Excellent service despite the crowd and rainy weather. Definitely deserving a return visit, and soon!

Islamorada Fish Company
KS
Katie Simon
google
05.24.2016
5/5

Loved the outside dining, delicious seafood, and friendly staff. Every year my family has to come back to dine again! The kids also enjoyed helping feed the tarpons and pelicans. The restaurant feeds them twice a day around lunch & dinner and allows the guests to participate. Fun times & tasty food.

Islamorada Fish Company
lm
lenka mezzano
google
05.09.2016
2/5

They have the best wahoo fish dip around and ok service, but the chef needs to not overcook the fish and use fresh seafood my hogfish dinner was terrible borderline inedible.The only reason I didn't send it back is because are waitress seemed nice and it wasn't her fault, deffinently would not go back unless I wanted fish dip.

Islamorada Fish Company
SK
Scott Kaduk
google
05.01.2016
5/5

The fish is always good best place in the keys to eat

Islamorada Fish Company
JS
Juan Sastre
google
04.27.2016
3/5

First timer--Food is good👍, was not completely satisfied service from waiter--- seems in a hurry -- no water placed @table unless asked --paper menu taken away??? asked french fries without salt but came with it👎 --note:: this is a trend in other restaurants since virus --where are the salt packets?

Islamorada Fish Company
JIMVO
google
04.17.2016
2/5

Sorry but it was much better a year or two ago...$20 for a fish sandwich...?

Islamorada Fish Company
CG
Carlos Gato
google
03.24.2016
4/5

It’s crazy packed for Covid but the staff are very accommodating. Great place to have a drink (pass on the Moscow mule) - have some oysters and take a nap in the sun.

Islamorada Fish Company
DR
David Rigg
google
03.18.2016
5/5

Great food and beautiful views. An iconic Keys restaurant

Islamorada Fish Company
EZ
Eve Z avila
google
03.16.2016
5/5

Always great food. A wait worth waiting for

Islamorada Fish Company
BM
Bob Milton
google
03.01.2016
4/5

It was good. Nice atmosphere and views. The food was not as good as the last time I was there, but good, and the service was just ok. Lots of people waiting so maybe taking great service for granted. Definitely worth the visit if you've never been.

Islamorada Fish Company
SS
Steven Smith
google
02.23.2016
5/5

Great bayside view and OMG the blueberry mojito is the best drink ever! We had hogfish strips encrusted in coconut batter and also just basted in Key lime butter (catch of the day). Outstanding!

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 13056649271

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!